Imagine this: You’ve just spent the day cheering on loved ones at a championship tournament, riding roller coasters at Cedar Point, or taking in the stunning views of Lake Erie. After all that adventure, one question remains: Where can you get the best pizza in town?
Luckily, Sandusky is home to several fantastic local pizzerias, offering everything from classic thin-crust slices to gourmet wood-fired specialties. Whether you’re dining in, grabbing takeout, or looking for late-night delivery, this guide has you covered.
And if you’re visiting Sandusky and need a comfortable place to stay, Explorer Rest and Recreation is the perfect home base for your trip.
The Best Pizza Restaurants in Sandusky, OH
Best Pizza for Families & Groups
Chet & Matt’s Pizza
Location: 1013 E. Strub Rd, Sandusky, OH 44870
What Makes It Special:
- Famous for the massive 29-inch ‘King Kong Pizza’—a must-try for big groups.
- Family-friendly restaurant with a sports bar vibe, great for catching a game.
- Offers more than just pizza—burgers, subs, wings, pasta, and appetizers are on the menu.
- A go-to spot for birthday parties and team celebrations.
Best For: Families, big groups, sports fans
Delivery: Check their website for availability.
Website: chetmattspizza.com
If you’re hungry for a challenge, the King Kong Pizza is legendary—just be prepared to share!
Best Classic Local Pizza Experience
Cameo Pizza
Location: 703 E. Strub Rd, Sandusky, OH 44870
What Makes It Special:
- A Sandusky staple since 1936, Cameo’s has been loved by locals for generations.
- Known for its “Cameo Sweet Fire” pizza, featuring a perfect mix of sweet and spicy toppings.
- Full-service restaurant and bar with a cozy, laid-back atmosphere.
- Offers other Italian favorites like pasta, sandwiches, and wings.
Best For: Classic pizza lovers, casual dining, historic Sandusky experience
Delivery: Available—check their website.
Website: cameopizza.com
If you’re looking for a pizza place with history and a great local reputation, Cameo Pizza is a must-visit.
Best Gourmet Pizza & Date Night Spot
Brick Oven Bistro
Location: 1012 Cleveland Rd, Sandusky, OH 44870
What Makes It Special:
- Specializes in brick oven-baked pizzas, creating a light, crispy crust with a smoky flavor.
- Unique specialty pizzas, including the Pear Gorgonzola Pizza, which blends sweet, savory, and tangy flavors.
- Offers a full menu of Italian dishes, from fresh salads to handcrafted pasta.
- Relaxed, stylish atmosphere with both indoor and outdoor seating.
Best For: Date nights, gourmet pizza lovers, outdoor dining
Delivery: Not specified—call ahead for details.
Website: https://brickovenohio.com/
If you love artisan-style pizza with unique toppings, Brick Oven Bistro is the perfect spot.
Best No-Fuss Local Favorite
Pizza House East & Pizza House West
Pizza House East: 604 Scott St, Sandusky, OH 44870
Pizza House West: 627 Tiffin Ave, Sandusky, OH 44870
What Makes Them Special:
- Local favorites since 1967, known for their classic, no-frills pizza.
- Traditional menu featuring pizza, subs, salads, and wings.
- Offers both carryout and delivery, making it a great option for a cozy night in.
- Friendly, family-owned atmosphere with consistently high ratings.
Best For: Traditional pizza lovers, locals, quick delivery
Delivery: Available for both locations.
Website: Pizza House East | Pizza House West
If you’re craving a simple, delicious, and affordable pizza, Pizza House East & West won’t disappoint.
Best for Late-Night Cravings & Unique Pizza
Pizza Brothers
Location: 4006 Milan Rd, Sandusky, OH 44870
What Makes It Special:
- Home of the ‘Foldover Pizza,’ a creative fusion of a sandwich and a pizza.
- Wide selection of gourmet pizzas, made with fresh, high-quality ingredients.
- Quick and reliable delivery, perfect for a late-night pizza fix.
- Offers exclusive deals and promotions throughout the week.
Best For: Late-night pizza, unique flavors, fast delivery
Delivery: Yes, available.
Website: https://sanduskypb.com/
If you’re looking for something different than your typical pizza, Pizza Brothers’ Foldover Pizza is worth trying.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
What is the best pizza place for delivery in Sandusky?
If you’re looking for fast and reliable delivery, Pizza Brothers and Pizza House East & West are top choices.
Which pizza place in Sandusky has the most unique toppings?
For creative toppings, Brick Oven Bistro offers gourmet combinations like the Pear Gorgonzola Pizza.
Where can I find the biggest pizza in Sandusky?
If you want a challenge, Chet & Matt’s Pizza serves up the 29-inch “King Kong Pizza”, perfect for sharing.
What is the best pizza place near Cedar Point?
Several options are within a short drive, but Cameo Pizza and Brick Oven Bistro are both excellent choices for visitors.
Final Thoughts
Sandusky is home to some of the best local pizza places, each offering a unique experience. Whether you’re in the mood for:
- A huge, shareable pizza (Chet & Matt’s Pizza)
- A classic, family-owned pizzeria (Cameo Pizza)
- A wood-fired, gourmet pizza (Brick Oven Bistro)
- A no-fuss, delicious local favorite (Pizza House East & West)
- A creative Foldover Pizza (Pizza Brothers)
You’re sure to find something for every pizza lover in your group!
Staying at Explorer Lodge? Our team is happy to recommend the best local eats! Book your stay at Explorer Rest & Recreation now and experience Sandusky like a local—with a slice of the city’s best pizza in hand.
Experienced Executive with a demonstrated history of working in the leisure and entertainment industry. Skilled in Strategic Development, Change Management, Executive-level Communication, Investor Relations, Mergers & Acquisitions, Corporate Finance, Valuation, and Due Diligence. Strong business development professional with a bachelor’s degree focused on Finance, General from Penn State University.
Leave a Reply